This is my first review, so comments are welcomed, to help me improve.
I use a hand fork more than any other tool on the allotment. Over the years I have tried and rejected quite a few, and although I am by no means an expert, I hope I can save you a few pounds by pointing out what to look for. At the bottom, there are my opinions of 6 Hand Forks, If you have one you would like me to review, I am happy to be contacted.
Tines
The prongs on the fork which you push into the soil, and you have some choices here
- Stainless Steel, Mild Steel or Plastic
- 3 or 4 Tines
- Forged, Pressed or Cast
- Flat or Round Tines
The cheapest fork will be plastic, and I promise you, you will regret buying it, so don't.
Of the metal forks, the best will be stainless steel (doesn't rust), Forged (much stronger, so it will last well) and Flat Tines (allows you to scoop out as well as agitate the soil)
As to 3 or 4 tines, I prefer 3, as it allows a bit more space between when weeding, but the choice is yours.
Tang
The "spike" which goes into the handle, and is attached to the tines.
Depending on which you have chosen above, the tang will either be part of the pressed steel, or a seperate part attached to the blade of your fork. I have found that the pressed steel forks will very quickly bend out of shape in this area. This is frustrating, and stops the work. If this happens to you, it is probably best to send it to recycling.
For preference, I like a good solid tang, welded to the blade.
Handle
There are choices here again.
- Plastic
- Wood
You must get a handle which feels comfortable in your hand. There are many shapes and patterns available, some with foam grip, some shaped with finger grips and traditional round.
Having tried most of these, I have to say, I can understand why the traditional handle became the tradition. It just feels right! The Foam coated handle was okay, until it got wet, then it was slippy. The shaped plastic handle I didn't get on with at all, it felt as if my hand was in the wrong place all the time, and the moulding had seems which gave me blisters.
All the above taken into account, we must next consider price. Before we do, lets consider that a good fork should last 20 years or more, a poor fork may get you through 2 or 3 sessions. If your budget will allow it, a good fork therefore is going to be much more cost effective. Look to spend up to £12 and no more, you will find excellent forks under this budget.
Ratings
Moulton Mill Stainless 10/10
Price around £8
Comfort ***** 5 stars
Quality ***** 5 stars
Notes My everyday workhorse. Kate bought this as part of a trowel and fork set for use at home. It was soon pressed in to service at the allotment, and is my new favourite! You can see it in use on my short "how to weed video"
here (links to a page on this blog)
The Fork is made by Gardman, has a 10 year guarantee, and uses FSC timber for the handle. This is an excellent fork, Highly recommended.
Joseph Bentley Stainless 9/10
Price around £10
Comfort ***** 5 stars
Quality **** 4 stars ( would be 5, but I managed to snap one)
Notes Lifetime guarantee! My broken fork was replaced, no problems. I like this fork and would it in preference to many of the others for almost every fork task on the allotment.
Wolf Garten 7/10
Price around £15 + £5 for the handle
Comfort *** 3 stars ( with optional handle)
Quality ***** 5 stars
Notes The handle attaches securely and is good and strong, but it is not very ergonomic. What is good though is that you can swap the handle to the long pole, and use the fork standing up
I like, and use this fork with the long pole, but the short handle has been consigned to the darkest recess of the shed
Wilkinson Sword Stainless 9/10
Price around £8
Comfort ***** 5 stars
Quality ****+ 4 stars +
Notes This is a good solid hand fork, although a bit more meat on the tines would be nice. It sits well in your hand, but it is possible to deform the tines in heavy soil. I would choose this fork if the Joseph Bentley was not available.
Silverline 4/10
Price around £4
Comfort *** 3 stars
Quality ** 2 stars
Notes If you need a fork on a tight budget, this one is okay. You will manage to bend the tines on heavy ground. The tines are coated to prevent rusting, but that wears off with continuous use. For light work this is an acceptable fork, and used with gloves, the handle isn't far off.
Gardman 3/10
Price around £3
Comfort ** 2 stars
Quality ** 2 stars
Notes I just didn't get on with this hand fork at all. After the first use the handle and fork came apart, and I had to make a repair by stuffing paper around the tine to make it secure. The handle feels wrong in the hand, it is too square at the end for me. This fork is fairly typical of the budget end, and would be okay for light work or window boxes.